Freedom
Toms River Church’s Fate Hangs in Balance as Controversy Erupts
In a troubling move that raises serious questions about the erosion of religious freedoms and the disregard for Christian compassion, the town council of Toms River, New Jersey, is aggressively pursuing the acquisition of Christ Episcopal Church’s historic 11-acre campus. This 160-year-old parish, a beacon of hope and support for the community, is currently seeking permission to establish a 17-bed shelter for the homeless—a mission that aligns perfectly with the Christian call to serve the least among us.
In a narrow 4-3 vote during an April 30 meeting, the council decided to proceed with plans to purchase the church and five other properties, or seize them if necessary, to construct two new public parks. Mayor Daniel Rodrick, who has been vocal in his criticism of homelessness, envisions pickleball courts, a soccer field, a playground, and a skate park replacing the church’s grounds.
The Rev. Lisa A. Hoffman, the church’s rector, expressed her shock and disappointment, stating, “It’s just really shocking and surprising and very disappointing.” The church was blindsided by this ordinance, learning of it mere hours before the vote, and no officials had the courtesy to notify the congregation in advance. Hoffman rightly questions the legitimacy of using the land for a park as a reason to seize church property.
Attorney Michael York, representing the church, highlighted the bad faith actions of the township and mayor, calling the ordinance “an excuse to obtain property.” He warned of impending litigation against officials who knowingly participate in this ill-conceived action. York pointed out that the township is in a “perilous position,” given the legal complexities involved, including the Episcopal Church’s Dennis Canon, which holds parish property in trust for the diocese and national church.
The council’s debate was brief but heated, with Council member Thomas Nivison unsuccessfully attempting to table the measure or exclude the church from consideration. James Quinlisk, who voted against the ordinance, passionately declared, “There’s no way on God’s green Earth that anyone should vote for this ordinance,” a sentiment that resonated with the audience, earning loud applause. In a powerful moment, David Ciccozzi stood to cast his no vote and led the room in the Lord’s Prayer, underscoring the deep faith that guides the church’s mission.
The church’s contributions to the community are invaluable. Each Sunday, more than 150 congregants gather for worship, and the church hosts over 20 support groups, operates a food pantry, and runs a weekly clothing giveaway. The property also houses the Ocean Christian Community and has been a base for the Affordable Housing Alliance, which has rehoused over 130 families in its first year.
This situation echoes a similar case in Bryan, Ohio, where a pastor faced legal challenges for keeping his church open to shelter the homeless. Such actions against churches dedicated to serving their communities are a stark reminder of the challenges facing religious institutions today.
As Christians, we are called to defend our faith and our freedoms. The actions of Toms River’s council not only threaten the church’s mission but also set a dangerous precedent for religious liberty. We must stand firm in our commitment to uphold traditional values, protect our places of worship, and ensure that the principles of faith, family, and freedom remain at the heart of our society.
Let us know what you think, please share your thoughts in the comments below.