Faith
Church Apology After Late-Night Choir Disruption
Faith Facts
- Christian humility calls for swift repentance and restoration in moments of discord.
- Church leaders are tasked to balance stewardship with gracious hospitality.
- Forgiveness and ongoing fellowship are pillars of biblical community life.
A recent incident at St Andrew church, Holborn in London, has reignited discussion about Christian leadership, congregational welcome, and the importance of grace in public witness.
During a summer evening, Bishop of Fulham Jonathan Baker interrupted a choir concert, declaring the music a “terrible racket” and insisting, “You are in my house. It’s gone past 10pm and this is a terrible racket.” He continued, “Goodnight. You are in my house – can you leave it now please. Thank you, it’s over.” His public rebuke, made barefoot and in his dressing gown, surprised hundreds gathered for the City Academy Voices choir’s concert.
The disruption occurred immediately after a rousing performance of “I’m Gonna Make You Love Me” by the Supremes and just before the planned finale, leaving several performers without the chance to sing. Video footage of the event soon made its rounds on social media, capturing the bishop’s remarks and audience boos. While the bishop stated concerns about the late hour, reports indicate the choir had booked the space until 11pm, and the incident happened just after 10pm.
The next day, recognizing the distress he caused, Bishop Baker issued a written apology to the choir and audience. “I write to apologise for the distress and offence which I caused on Friday evening in bringing the City Voices concert to a premature end,” he stated. He accepted responsibility for ending the event early, admitting his actions were hasty and assuring those affected, “I take full responsibility and apologise unreservedly.” In humility, he further shared, “I also apologise for remarks which were made in haste and which have understandably caused hurt and distress.”
Emphasizing a foundation of Christian hospitality, the bishop committed to ongoing partnership, noting, “You have been, and continue to be, welcome and I hope that you will be able to continue the relationship with us.” He added, “I can give you every assurance that the events of Friday evening will not recur and I apologise again to performers (especially those unable to perform at the end of the evening) and audience alike.”
In moments of public conflict, the call to humility and repentance stands as a crucial witness to biblical faith and the transformative power of grace. This incident affirms how church leaders, when faced with error, can model Christ-like restoration—maintaining both righteous stewardship and a spirit of forgiveness that keeps doors open to new fellowship and continued faithful service.